Shockingly High Levels of Lead Found in Fashion Accessories Sold at Off-Price Retailers

Leading US off-price retailers Ross and Burlington continue to sell leather and faux leather fashion accessories containing high levels of toxic lead, says a report by nonprofit watchdog Center for Environmental Health (CEH).

Long Story, Cut Short
  • More than a decade after the CEH began testing for lead in fashion accessories, it still routinely found lead-containing fashion accessories at off-price retailers like Burlington, Marshalls, Nordstrom Rack, Ross, and TJ Maxx.
  • Over the last decade, CEH has notified retailers Burlington, Marshalls, Nordstrom Rack, Ross, and TJ Maxx nearly 500 times that they were selling specific fashion accessories containing elevated levels of lead.
  • CEH found more faux leather than genuine leather fashion accessories contained lead.
At both Ross and Burlington, the majority (87%) of lead-containing handbags and wallets sampled in 2022 showed a pattern of faux leather materials on the interior lining of the bags containing excessive levels of lead, whereas the exterior faux-leather material tended to be lead-free.
Lead concerns At both Ross and Burlington, the majority (87%) of lead-containing handbags and wallets sampled in 2022 showed a pattern of faux leather materials on the interior lining of the bags containing excessive levels of lead, whereas the exterior faux-leather material tended to be lead-free. Lee Campbell / Unsplash

A study spanning 13 years has found high levels of toxic lead in leather and faux leather fashion accessories including handbags, wallets, shoes, and belts sold at leading US off-price retailers Ross and Burlington.

  • In 2022 alone, more than 25% of the fashion accessories purchased from Ross and Burlington and tested contained elevated lead levels above 0.03% and up to 1.7%, nonprofit watchdog Center for Environmental Health (CEH) has said in a report.
  • Over the last decade, CEH has notified retailers Burlington, Marshalls, Nordstrom Rack, Ross, and TJ Maxx nearly 500 times that they were selling specific fashion accessories containing elevated levels of lead. Ross and Burlington accounted for over 300 of those notices.
  • This report was authored by CEH staff Caitlin Moher and Martin Bañuelos.

THE DANGER: Employees and consumers working and shopping in Ross and Burlington’s over 2,500 retail locations can be exposed to lead in these fashion accessories when they touch the products with their hands and then touch their mouths.

  • Exposure can put people at a higher risk of high blood pressure and kidney damage and can put pregnant people at a risk of reproductive harm.
  • Additionally, if children are exposed to lead through these products, they can face irreversible behavioural changes and learning difficulties.

THE KEY FACTS:   Ross and Burlington cater to lower-income consumers, and most of their California storefronts are located in communities already facing environmental, health, and other socioeconomic pressures.

  • CEH found more faux leather than genuine leather fashion accessories contained lead. Lead was more frequently observed in belts sold attached to clothes as a set than in belts sold as stand-alone products.
  • At both Ross and Burlington, the majority (87%) of lead-containing handbags and wallets sampled in 2022 showed a pattern of faux leather materials on the interior lining of the bags containing excessive levels of lead, whereas the exterior faux-leather material tended to be lead-free.
  • In 2022, CEH found, over half of lead-containing fashion accessories purchased at Ross and Burlington had Proposition 65 warnings. Some of these warnings were hidden in small print, on tags inside of handbags, and on the bottom of shoes.
  • In 2022, CEH found that the interior lining of faux leather handbags and wallets more frequently contained lead than the exterior lining.

THE PROBLEM WITH LEAD: Lead is a toxic chemical that can cause permanent and irreversible health effects at small doses, according to the World Health Organization [WHO].

  • Exposure to lead can cause cancer, reproductive issues, and neurological harm. There is no safe level of lead exposure.

THE BACKDROP: In 2009, the CEH began testing leather and faux leather polyurethane and polyvinyl chloride fashion accessories, including handbags, wallets, footwear, and belts, for lead.

  • It found that hundreds of large fashion companies were manufacturing and distributing fashion accessories with high levels of lead. This was a cause for concern, as handling these items can contaminate our hands with lead that can then be ingested when we touch our mouth.
  • By 2011, the CEH had successfully used the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986, commonly known as Proposition 65, to force hundreds of companies to stop manufacturing and distributing leather and faux leather fashion accessories with high levels of lead.
  • In 2012, the CEH established a testing strategy to ensure leather and faux leather fashion accessories on the market, including ones sold by the companies that we reached legally binding agreements with, no longer contained high levels of lead.
  • Each year, the Centre tested fashion accessories and found that more and more companies were reformulating their products, making it harder to find lead in products sold at big-box, department, and fast fashion retailers in California.
  • However, the problem had not been completely eliminated. More than a decade after the CEH began testing for lead in fashion accessories, it still routinely found lead-containing fashion accessories at off-price retailers, like Burlington, Marshalls, Nordstrom Rack, Ross, and TJ Maxx.
  • In 2022, CEH re-focused the testing strategy on products from Ross and Burlington, two of the largest and most affordable off-price retailers in the US.
  • The Centres’ investigators purchased more than 1,950 shoes, handbags, wallets, and belts suspected of containing lead from Ross and Burlington storefronts across California, located in communities facing varying degrees of environmental, health, and socioeconomic pressures, as determined by CalEnviroScreen ratings.
  • The CEH found that both Ross and Burlington continue to sell lead-containing footwear, handbags, wallets and belts.
Toxic Fashion
Toxic Fashion
How Off-Price Retailers Expose Shoppers to Lead
  • Authored by:

    Caitlin Moher and Martin Bañuelos

  • Publisher: Center for Environmental Health
  • 24
 
 
  • Dated posted: 13 March 2024
  • Last modified: 13 March 2024