Fashion Africa: It's about Breaking Free from the Resource Curse

The unique opportunity presented by the availability of high-quality local fibres, the rich array of handwoven, hand-processed or industrial textiles produced on the continent, and the strength of the demand for African designs means that the sector is ripe for new investments and policies. Unless, the West reads “ripe for investment” as “ripe for plunder.”

Long Story, Cut Short
  • The theory of the resource curse has mostly been confined to the Western plunder of natural resources, and yet it is the first thought that inevitably crosses one's mind while leafing through the recent UNESCO report Africa's fashion ecosystem.
  • The richness and diversity of Africa's cultural tapestry is untold, and yet remains the poorest block in the global fashion ecosystem.
  • By exporting most of its raw fibres, the continent sees a consistent significant loss in the potential economic value of these crops and restricts the growth of the textile and fashion value chain in Africa.
Africa is still a minor contributor to overconsumption and its fashion industry has the opportunity to “get things right” from the start and become global leaders in sustainable fashion. While many African designers are already integrating sustainability in textile waste management through fashion fibre-to-fibre recycling or through other optimised processes focused on recycling and reuse, consumer behaviour in particular can be influenced by promoting a culture of reuse and resale, followed by recycling an
Fashioning it right Africa is still a minor contributor to overconsumption and its fashion industry has the opportunity to “get things right” from the start and become global leaders in sustainable fashion. While many African designers are already integrating sustainability in textile waste management through fashion fibre-to-fibre recycling or through other optimised processes focused on recycling and reuse, consumer behaviour in particular can be influenced by promoting a culture of reuse and resale, followed by recycling and repurposing. Trevor Stuurman / UNESCO

The UNESCO editorial team was led by Toussaint Tiendrebeogo, Chief of the Diversity of Cultural Expressions Entity, and included Doyun Lee, Gabrielle Thiboutot, Lotfi Aoulad, Patricia Huang and Caroline Bordoni. 

The report was prepared by Culture and Development East Africa (Ayeta Wangusa and Yarri Kamara), and draws on research and consultations conducted by Adwoa Owusuaa Bobie, The Rock Group (Karin Boomsma and Elise Sormani), and with the support of Yasmine Hussein, Elizabeth Mbabazi Kagwa, Florence Mukanga Majachani, Diana Ramarohetra, and Rania Tarhouni. 

This publication is available in Open Access under the Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 IGO (CC-BY-SA 3.0 IGO) license.

Certain ground truths don't change. They nag away as conspiratorial suspicions till someone either finally quantifies them or gives the axioms a definitive name.

Something of this sort began as an astute observation roughly two decades before John Kay had even patented the flying shuttle. A newspaper called The Spectator (no relation to the current namesake) in 1711 remarked: "It is generally observed, that in countries of the greatest plenty there is the poorest living." Exploitation had been understood long before Karl Marx was to study various aspects of the textile-driven Industrial Revolution and quantify it as surplus value.

The idea oscillated between being that festering suspicion and an irrefutable confirmation till economist Richard Auty in 1993 gave it a name, shape and form: the resource curse. The term, since, has triggered and dominated debates of exploitation, and nowhere has this (exploitation) been more pronounced than in Africa (and also South America, if you please).

But, the theory of the resource curse has mostly been confined to the Western plunder of natural resources, and yet it is the first thought that inevitably crosses one's mind while leafing through the recent UNESCO report Africa's fashion ecosystem. The richness and diversity of Africa's cultural tapestry is untold, and yet remains the poorest block in the global fashion ecosystem.

Sure, the report—titled The Fashion Sector in Africa: Trends, Challenges and Opportunities for Growth—we have at hand is from UNESCO.  This means that certain elements like the politics of exploitation would be missing from the context. But joining the dots would not be difficult, since the document is a fairly well-documented primer. The report is also heavily inclined towards apparel and design, essentially meaning that issue of natural resources and the politics of trade, for instance, are nowhere to be found.

Nevertheless, it is a good start.

The high fashion sector, the report argues, can serve as a conduit for safeguarding traditional skills and intangible cultural heritage practices, while generating revenues for a range of craftworkers and pioneering sustainable practices.
High on fashion The high fashion sector, the report argues, can serve as a conduit for safeguarding traditional skills and intangible cultural heritage practices, while generating revenues for a range of craftworkers and pioneering sustainable practices. Luke Kitchin / UNESCO

The trends to go by

To be fair, the report does not dwell too much on the past, and goes straight into how many African fashion producers consciously have "cast themselves as agents of socio-cultural change who contributed to the self-fashioning of their countries and continent, whilst also promoting economic growth and generating employment opportunities."

It says: "Thanks to their unique heritage, unreplicable technical skills, and distinctive creative vision, contemporary African fashion designers connect the dots between the past and present, tapping into their cultural roots to create clothes and accessories that help to shape unique and ever-renewed visual narratives about the identity and aspirations of the continent."

The African fashion landscape is dotted with countless micro, small, and medium enterprises (MSMEs), “which tend to serve a hyper-local market with ready-to-wear and made-to-order clothes and accessories. High-fashion brands do exist today, but they are few and far between, and are mostly concentrated in Côte d’Ivoire, Ghana, Kenya, Nigeria, Rwanda, Senegal, and South Africa. Then there is today’s growing apparel export sector, which caters to Western brands and retailers.

But, Africa is deep-rooted in its own textiles, and the natural fibres that they come from. Cotton, by far, is the primary natural fibre. As many as 37 of the 54 African countries grow cotton, though the yield, volume and quality vary among them. Cotton is also a predominant cash crop for many African Least Developed Countries (LDCs), providing income to over 3.5 million farmers. Organic cotton too figures in the discussion. The organic cotton fibre output in Sub-Saharan Africa grew by over 90% from 2019 to 2020, and accounted for 7.3% of global organic cotton production.

Significant quantities of wool are manufactured in Southern and Northern African countries, and silk is produced in in Ethiopia, Madagascar, Namibia, and South Africa. Then, there are the artisanal fibres of raffia (Cameroon, Congo, Côte d’Ivoire, Democratic Republic of the Congo, Liberia, Madagascar, Nigeria) and tree bark (Côte d’Ivoire, Ghana, Uganda). Jute, kenaf, coir, flax, sisal, ramie, kapok, and abaca—all are produced and used, though to a lesser extent.

All this would make Africa the land of plenty. It does, but it is also here that the Black Hole lies—a lot of the cotton disappears out of Africa. The report underlines: “In 2022, while African cotton fibre production accounted for 7.5% of global production, sub-Saharan countries exported more than 81% of the raw cotton they produced rather than transforming and using it locally. By exporting most of its raw fibres, the continent sees a consistent significant loss in the potential economic value of these crops and restricts the growth of the textile and fashion value chain in Africa.

There are few who buck this trend. “Egypt, the eleventh largest exporter of raw cotton globally in 2022, also transforms a significant quantity of fibres domestically to meet national demand and feed its flourishing textile industry. Both Egyptian cotton fibre and fabric have a reputation for quality, and the Cotton Egypt Association has developed an Egyptian Cotton appellation to distinguish its product on the market, ensuring traceability through DNA tests.

“Similarly, Ethiopia strives to link its fibre production to its textile production as part of its recent drive to develop its garments sector. In 2020, the country produced 57,000 metric tonnes of cotton fibre, satisfying a significant part of demand from domestic spinning mills, estimated at 64,000 metric tonnes.”

The hope also lies in influential fashion designers like Alphadi, the Nigerien also known by the sobriquet ‘Magician of the Desert’. His comments in the report probably sum up a lot of the past, present and future of African fashion: “African textiles must be given a chance. They must be produced on the African continent. I am in favour of limiting the entry of imported textiles into the continent.

“I have difficulty purchasing large quantities of textiles from Africa. I refuse to import, and it directly impacts my production capacities as well as my costs. It is not normal. Africa should have the capacity to industrially produce textiles. It is difficult to make ready-to-wear collections with these constraints. Our fashion remains reserved for a minority because of production costs.”

Alphadi
Alphadi
Fashion Designer
Niger

I have difficulty purchasing large quantities of textiles from Africa. I refuse to import, and it directly impacts my production capacities as well as my costs. It is not normal. Africa should have the capacity to industrially produce textiles. It is difficult to make ready-to-wear collections with these constraints. Our fashion remains reserved for a minority because of production costs.

At present, the African fashion sector is a hothouse of remarkable talent and brimming with potential, with established and emerging creators and designers combining traditional knowhow with innovation and creativity to create products that run the gamut between exquisite high fashion and mass-produced affordable garments and accessories.
Limitless Potential At present, the African fashion sector is a hothouse of remarkable talent and brimming with potential, with established and emerging creators and designers combining traditional knowhow with innovation and creativity to create products that run the gamut between exquisite high fashion and mass-produced affordable garments and accessories. Sunny Dolat / UNESCO

Taking it forward

Clubbing all countries of a continent together can never be fair, or even logical. There cannot be one “African fashion”—there are at least 54 African fashions. For the same reason, summing up challenges can be a thankless task too. But the report quite deftly weaves together the common threads, and poses them as a fabric with five distinct features:

  1. The patchwork of support policies currently in place in most countries;
  2. The insufficient implementation of intellectual property rights in the fashion sector;
  3. The gaps in fashion education and training;
  4. The lack of structured investments and infrastructure; and
  5. Specific market challenges and environmental concerns. 

These challenges can be surmounted, and the report lists out four sets of recommendations. It also details sector-specific growth levers. 

Yet, somewhere in the report, this is outlined: “The unique opportunity presented by the availability of high-quality local fibres, the rich array of handwoven, hand-processed or industrial textiles produced on the continent, and the strength of the demand for African designs means that the sector is ripe for new investments and policies.”

Unless, the West reads “ripe for investment” as “ripe for plunder.”

The African Fashion Sector
The African Fashion Sector
Trends, Challenges and Opportunities for Growth
  • Publisher: UNESCO
  • ISBN: 978-92-3-100618-0
  • 82

OVERARCHING RECOMMENDATIONS FOR THE FASHION SECTOR

COMPREHENSIVE AND INCLUSIVE POLICIES FOR THE FASHION ECOSYSTEM
  • Integrate the fashion ecosystem into national development plans and/or strategies
  • Enact inter-ministerial coordination to guide the development of the fashion sector
  • Develop or strengthen intellectual property legislation
  • Enhance data collection and analysis
ENSURING FAIR REMUNERATION AND DECENT WORK IN THE FASHION SECTOR
  • Protect traditional crafts, designs, and know-how
  • Ensure decent working conditions in the fashion sector in line with international standards paying specific attention to gender equality
  • Facilitate the establishment of trade unions of professional organizations in the textile, garment, high fashion, accessories, and fine crafts sectors
PROMOTING STRUCTURED INVESTMENTS AND INFRA DEVELOPMENT
  • Create an enabling and attractive business environment for stakeholders and investors in the fashion sector
  • Improve access to financing opportunities for fashion MSMEs and SMEs, with targeted support for women and youth
  • Facilitate regional and international trade
  • Strengthen ties with the African diaspora by facilitating investment in the fashion sector
LEADING THE WAY FOR SUSTAINABLE FASHION

Africa is still a minor contributor to overconsumption and its fashion industry has the opportunity to “get things right” from the start and become global leaders in sustainable fashion. While many African designers are already integrating sustainability in textile waste management through fashion fibre-to-fibre recycling or through other optimised processes focused on recycling and reuse, consumer behaviour in particular can be influenced by promoting a culture of reuse and resale, followed by recycling and repurposing.

Subir Ghosh

SUBIR GHOSH is a Kolkata-based independent journalist-writer-researcher who writes about environment, corruption, crony capitalism, conflict, wildlife, and cinema. He is the author of two books, and has co-authored two more with others. He writes, edits, reports and designs. He is also a professionally trained and qualified photographer.

 
 
 
  • Dated posted: 22 November 2023
  • Last modified: 22 November 2023