Luxury Loot: LVMH’s Loro Piana Has Monopoly over Expensive Vicuña Wool, But Poor Indigenous Farmers in Peru Need to Work for Free

LVMH is one of the biggest and richest luxury conglomerates in the world, and the vicuña wool for its Loro Piana brand is exquisite and expensive. But the indigenous farmers in Peru remain impoverished and exploited, an investigation by Bloomberg has revealed.

Long Story, Cut Short
  • The vicuña (Lama vicugna) is one of the two wild South American camelids, which live in the high alpine areas of the Andes.
  • The community in Lucanas was the first to shear the vicuña in 1994, and Loro Piana has been its buyer ever since.
  • The rate paid to the people of Lucanas for raw fibre has fallen 36% in the past decade.
The erstwhile Alberto Fujimori government had issued a decree giving companies the same rights as peasant communities to shear vicuña found on their property.
LVMH Property The erstwhile Alberto Fujimori government had issued a decree giving companies the same rights as peasant communities to shear vicuña found on their property. Loro Nipana has been making the best of it, even buying land and creating a 12.5km fence around its property, which would ensure that the vicuña wouldn’t leave and get sheared by others. wildercr / Pixabay

Loro Piana, the brand owned by the luxury conglomerate LVMH, has done virtually nothing for the indigenous peoples of the Peruvian Andes from where it has been sourcing the world's finest and most expensive wool, an investigation by Bloomberg has found.

  • A sweater made from vicuña wool sells for $9,000 in high-street outlets in Europe and the US, but the indigenous community in the Lucanas province in Peru gets only $280 for an equivalent amount of fibre. This is not enough to pay members of the community, who have to work for free, according to the Bloomberg report.

THE VICUÑA: The vicuña (Lama vicugna) is one of the two wild South American camelids, which live in the high alpine areas of the Andes, the other being the guanaco, which lives at lower elevations, according to Wikipedia.

  • Until 1964, hunting of the vicuña was unrestricted, which reduced its numbers to only 6,000 in the 1960s. As a result, the species was declared endangered in 1974, and its status prohibited the trade of vicuña wool.
  • Poachers would shoot and skin the vicuña instead of shearing them.
  • During 1964–66, the Servicio Forestal y de Caza in cooperation with the US Peace Corps, Nature Conservancy, World Wildlife Fund, and the National Agrarian University of La Molina established a nature conservatory for the vicuña called the Pampa Galeras – Barbara D'Achille in Lucanas province. 
  • The Convention for the Conservation of the Vicuña helped reinstate a legal market while dictating that income derived from vicuñas benefit Indigenous Andean peoples, a historically impoverished population.

THE PEOPLE AND THE WOOL: The community in Lucanas was the first to shear the vicuña in 1994, and Loro Piana has been its buyer ever since

  • However, the trade—according to the Bloomberg investigation—has done little for the 2,700 members of the community. Most houses are made of mud, and don’t have plumbing. Older residents are subsistence farmers while the younger lot either move to cities or work in the unregulated gold mines in the region.

TRADING IN WOOL: Loro Piana’s prices have kept rising. The rate paid to the people of Lucanas for raw fibre, however, has fallen 36% in the past decade. 

  • In 2018 a government-commissioned study found that 80% of those living in the town said they hadn’t benefited from the community’s participation in the trade. 
  • Andrea Barrientos, a 75-year-old subsistence farmer quoted by Bloomberg, has never had an opportunity to make a vicuña garment. She’s never even seen one.

THE LORO PIANA STRANGLEHOLD: After the Maoist insurgency of the Shining Path came to an end, the new government of Alberto Fujimori allowed vicuña fibre sales to restart.

  • The Fujimori government set the stage for a monopoly and Loro Piana became the main investor in a three-member conglomerate. In 1994 the first legal shearing of vicuñas in decades was done in Lucanas, and the following year, Peru granted indigenous communities the exclusive right to shear and sell vicuña fibre, as long as the animals were found within their territories. Loro Piana and others would have to enter into commercial agreements with communities to access the vicuña.
  • Just as his government fell because of corruption accusations, Fujimori issued a decree giving companies the same rights as peasant communities to shear vicuña found on their property. So, companies could buy land in the Andes and shear the animals there. 
  • Alfonso Martinez, head of the vicuña market regulator, pushed for the change behind the scenes, and later set up a company that worked as an intermediary between indigenous communities and corporations. In 2007, he became the chief executive officer of Lora Piana’s Peruvian operations.
  • Loro Piana bought 4,942 acres of barren land near Lucanas for $160,000, and got a vicuña shearing permit. Loro Piana proposed creating a 12.5km fence around its property, which would ensure that the vicuña wouldn’t leave and get sheared by others. 
  • The animals would reproduce fast, enabling the population to grow annually by 50%. So, Loro Piana was the first company to shear vicuña without paying indigenous communities for the fibre. 
  • Peasant communities in Peru have an elected president who can decide how to use and redistribute community resources; in Lucanas, the rule is that community members must work for free in the roundup, while outsiders can be paid, usually about $20 a day.
The Vicuña Bomber Jacket sells for €9,800.
The Vicuña Bomber Jacket sells for €9,800. Loro Piana / LVMH
 
 
  • Dated posted: 19 March 2024
  • Last modified: 20 March 2024