Smallholder Farmer Groups Need Best Possible Support to Adapt to Climate Change

As the Regenerative Agriculture & Textiles Summit 2023 gets going today at Washington DC to discuss ways and means to accelerate regenerative agriculture practices through collaborative efforts, Inka Sachse, Project Manager, Standards & Outreach at Aid by Trade Foundation, talks about how these two days will try to understand stakeholder challenges, drive solutions and build partnerships across industries.

Long Story, Cut Short
  • The Regenerative Cotton Standard (RCS) is holistic with a commercial focus on cotton; it includes the entire crop rotation, social criteria, as well as basic needs of farm animals.
  • RCS unites the strong social, environmental, health and safety and smallholder focus of Cotton made in Africa (CmiA) Standard, with a farmer community-focused approach towards the transformation to regenerative farming systems.
Apart from the soil health approach, on which the industrialised regenerative farming stakeholder community entirely agrees upon, RCS considers the importance of rooting the transformation in traditional farming knowledge. Traditional ways of farming must be respected, valued, supported, and combined with what science knows today in order to reach not just some kind of proof of impact, but true ownership in the farming communities.
Traditional Route Apart from the soil health approach, on which the industrialised regenerative farming stakeholder community entirely agrees upon, RCS considers the importance of rooting the transformation in traditional farming knowledge. Traditional ways of farming must be respected, valued, supported, and combined with what science knows today in order to reach not just some kind of proof of impact, but true ownership in the farming communities. Ollivier Girard / CIFOR

Note: This interview is brought to you in association with the Regenerative Agriculture & Textiles Summit 2023, which gets under way on Tuesday 14 November. texfash.com is a Media Partner at the event. This interview can be downloaded from the organiser's website.

What are the key principles or criteria of the Regenerative Cotton Standard (RCS) of the Aid by Trade Foundation?
Inka Sachse: RCS unites the strong social, environmental, health and safety and smallholder focus of our Cotton made in Africa (CmiA) Standard, with a farmer community-focused approach towards the transformation to regenerative farming systems. Generally, RCS, as well as CmiA, target organised groups of cotton-producing family farmers around a so-called ‘Managing Entity’ (e.g., a cotton company), who trains and supports farmers, organises the material flow, and acts as the gateway for verification. To enable Managing Entities to engage with smallholder farming communities more actively, our partnering cotton companies have started participating in trainings with African People and Wildlife in Tanzania.

Apart from the soil health approach, on which the industrialised regenerative farming stakeholder community entirely agrees upon, RCS considers the importance of rooting the transformation in traditional farming knowledge. Traditional ways of farming must be respected, valued, supported, and combined with what science knows today in order to reach not just some kind of proof of impact, but true ownership in the farming communities. The approach is on the one hand very strategic and on the other, hands-on. Wherever possible, farmers can choose which practices suit them to improve their biggest challenges.

RCS evolves around 10 principles:

  1. Farm resilience is improved;
  2. Farming families’ livelihoods are improved;
  3. Transparency and fairness in co-operation are ensured;
  4. Decent working conditions are observed;
  5. Soil health is restored;
  6. Water resources are preserved;
  7. The climate is protected;
  8. The reduction and safe use of synthetic inputs are ensured;
  9. Biodiversity is enhanced; and 
  10. Animal needs are respected.

The three enabling requirements: responsible management, community engagement, and combination of traditional knowledge and science, form the basis of each principle. RCS comes along with community business opportunities that support RCS-associated farming systems.

RCS is holistic: with a commercial focus on cotton; it  includes the entire crop rotation, social criteria, as well as basic needs of farm animals.

So far, what have been your experiences in implementing the standard? What are the potential challenges in implementing the standard on a larger scale, and how can these challenges be addressed?
Inka Sachse: RCS has just been launched. We are currently discussing the piloting with several local partners e.g. cotton companies who organise and support small-scale farmers.

Each partner environment comes with their own strengths and weaknesses. Many of our current partners are already engaged in regenerative practices in one way or another, e.g., regarding agroforestry, cover crops, biochar production, or composting, or via supporting specific farmer group initiatives. With RCS, we’re systematising to value and continuously improve the already existing agronomic or training innovations.

We are building on 18 years of experience in the field in a smallholder context with the CmiA standard and are now ready to move deeper and further with our impact. We expect that the holistic approach (crop rotation surfaces, animal welfare, community engagement) will bring challenges in verification during the first phase but are piloting remote sensing technologies at the same time. So far, we have received great interest from existing and potential new partners, and they are excited to implement RCS.

The Regenerative Cotton Standard is building on 18 years of experience in the field in a smallholder context with the CmiA standard. It expects that the holistic approach (crop rotation surfaces, animal welfare, community engagement) will bring challenges in verification during the first phase but are piloting remote sensing technologies at the same time.
Holistic Approach The Regenerative Cotton Standard is building on 18 years of experience in the field in a smallholder context with the CmiA standard. It expects that the holistic approach (crop rotation surfaces, animal welfare, community engagement) will bring challenges in verification during the first phase but are piloting remote sensing technologies at the same time. Carsten ten Brink / Flickr 2.0

How can collaboration be an effective tool for promoting the adoption of standard?
Inka Sachse: Our experience is that brands like to promote cooperation with certain farmer groups—be it around carbon, or biodiversity, or with a broader e.g. regenerative focus.
We consider the impact of this practice limited, as just selected communities benefit, and the brand’s outside communication evolves around successes of this selected group. We also repeatedly experience that both do not understand what the other side means. 

The Aid by Trade Foundation bridges the requirements of the brands, who like to have a product with an impactful story and sustainable value, with the needs and realities of the local partners and farming communities. We speak the language of both sides and channel the brand engagement to avail equal benefits to all farmers. At the same time, we assure that the engagement of the local partners, who organise the farmers, reaches at least a certain validated level. That’s what the brands pay their license fee for.

What is the long-term vision for the regenerative cotton standard and how do you see it evolving in the coming years to support the transition to regenerative agriculture?
Inka Sachse: Smallholder farmer groups need the best possible support to adapt to climate change. Now we see great market potential for regenerative cotton. We expect that there will be more regenerative standards and origins on different and unharmonised levels.  We want to use this momentum to offer a reliable alternative and thereby to benefit the producers as well as the brands.

However, as “Regenerative” has no official definition, we also expect that the term may be interpreted as e.g. “sustainable agriculture”, an approach which may become subject to criticism in the future. RCS provides a holistic and future-proof standard reaching far beyond the biggest common denominator “soil health”.


What are you most excited about at this year’s Regenerative Agriculture & Textiles Summit 2023?
Inka Sachse: We are very proud to announce our third standard to this audience and to answer questions and gain feedback.

We love to interact with brands, retailers and peers on the ideas behind RCS. We’d like to foster the exchange on the feasibility of holistic standards in smallholder contexts (e.g. on feasible and payable monitoring and verification).

We’d like to discuss good examples, on how community engagement can be helpful within regenerative standards...

That’s why we’re hosting the roundtable session C: Certification to promote responsible regenerative agriculture management:

  • what regenerative certifications for textiles are available, how do they differentiate and what are possible gaps?
  • what should a new regenerative cotton standard for smallholder environments entail?
  • shared experiences in certifying agricultural smallholder environments.
Inka Sachse
Inka Sachse
Project Manager (Standards & Outreach)
Aid by Trade Foundation

Smallholder farmer groups need the best possible support to adapt to climate change. Now we see great market potential for regenerative cotton. We expect that there will be more regenerative standards and origins on different and unharmonised levels. We want to use this momentum to offer a reliable alternative and thereby to benefit the producers as well as the brands.

 
 
  • Dated posted: 14 November 2023
  • Last modified: 14 November 2023