Study Calls for Multi-Level Coordination Between Exporting and Importing Countries, Involving Affected Communities

The textile waste crisis calls for a well-coordinated multilevel approach between exporting and importing countries, and a mix of measures that engage all authorities and stakeholders concerned with local environmental and social issues, says a new report.

Long Story, Cut Short
  • Textile waste, whether from second-hand clothing entering a country or from new clothing purchased by nationals, requires a strategy to prevent it from becoming waste and to keep it as a productive factor in the economy.
  • The report has called for incorporating relevant clauses in international trade agreements, besides enforcing restrictions in exporting countries and bolstering circular practices in importing nations.
  • The report looks at the global problem through the example of Chile.
Women search for used clothes amid tonnes of discarded items in the Atacama desert, in Alto Hospicio, Iquique, Chile.
Waste Around Women search for used clothes amid tonnes of discarded items in the Atacama desert, in Alto Hospicio, Iquique, Chile. AFP Photo

No single solution can reduce the massive volume of used garments, most of which have little economic value, that end up as textile waste around the developing world, a new study has concluded.

  • A multilevel approach that is well coordinated between exporting and importing countries, and one that involves national and subnational authorities alongside affected communities, can tackle the textile waste crisis that has swamped the Global South.
  • The report has also called for incorporating relevant clauses in international trade agreements, besides enforcing restrictions in exporting countries and bolstering circular practices in importing nations.
  • The conclusion comes from a report recently published by United Nations Economic Commission for Europe (UNECE) and the United Nations Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean (ECLAC). The report is titled Reversing direction in the used clothing crisis: Global, European and Chilean perspectives.
  • The report looks at the global problem through the example of Chile.

THE OVERALL CONCLUSIONS: The report also drew other conclusions:

  • Implementing this mix of measures requires the engagement of all authorities and stakeholders concerned with local environmental and social issues. Their members are aware of the multidimensionality of the challenges to be addressed and have already implemented solutions on a small scale, as reported by this study.
  • In the end there is a need for systemic solutions that reduce the volume of new clothes put on the market, ensure clothes are designed to be free of toxic chemicals, and encourage longer use phases and multiple cycles of reuse. In short, a circular economy for fashion.

MOVING FORWARD: The next steps for UN ECE and UN ECLAC off the back of this report are to engage with government partners in the EU and Chile on the issues raised in this report, reach out to stakeholders across the value chain to convene working groups on systemic solutions, and to seek to align legislation in the EU and Chile to enable the increased circularity of textile flows domestically and internationally.

  • An example of outreach to government partners is the partnership between UN ECLAC and the Chilean government on Technical Assistance. Objectives for this programme include: incorporating an international trade dimension into Chile’s National Strategy for Circular Economy in Textiles (ENECT); promoting complementarity between Chile’s EPR Law and ENECT; and developing public-private cooperation to increase levels of traceability and transparency in fashion industry value chains.

THE STUMBLING BLOCKS: The report contends that increased global trade in used clothes is driven fundamentally by shifts in the fashion industry in recent decades that have led to increases in volumes of clothes produced and reductions in their quality, making circularity difficult:

  1. The fast-fashion revolution of the past several decades, characterised by rapid turnover of styles, has led to large increases in the production and disposal of low-quality textiles
  2. This model is facilitated by the advent of low-cost synthetic fibres and by trade liberalisation that allowed the offshoring of production to countries with low-wage labour
  3. Large proportions of clothing are made from difficult-to-separate blended fibres, making opportunities for economic reuse and recycling rare, particularly in developed countries.

MAKING IT WORK: The study makes a slew of recommendations, but primarily from a Chile-EU perspective. However, these can be adapted by other countries and geo-political entities.

Make changes to international trade agreements:

  • Develop minimum international criteria for second-hand clothing exports to ensure that importing countries only receive garments that have a market value, or that can be recycled.
  • Agree between both parties on legal definitions of ‘textile waste’ and ‘second-hand clothing’ and establish quality restrictions on their import from exporting countries. 
  • Set internationally agreed standards to clearly distinguish between second-hand clothing and textile waste and establish mechanisms to track their trade flows by building on existing UN work in partnership with international and regional players.

Pursue domestic policy action in importing countries: 

  • Adopt administrative measures at the port of Iquique to ensure digital traceability of flows of second-hand clothing and textile waste, based on international standards (i.e. the UNECE-UN/CEFACT traceability standard).
  • Digitise all shipment, transport, and control procedures to help avoid smuggling and transporting waste to illegal dumps.
  • Introduce automated customs declarations, electronic cargo tracking, risk-based inspections, and digital inventory controls to improve traceability. In addition, provisions for infrastructure improvements should be in place to ensure that goods destined for bonded warehouses can be transported from the port of entry safely and efficiently
  • Use customs cooperation and mutual support agreements with trading partners to increase information exchange. These agreements can serve as effective mechanisms for customs officials to track exports before they are shipped or when they are sent to a third country and then re-exported to that country.
  • Establish a Circular Economy Strategy for Textiles covering the entire process from import, through incorporation into new production processes, to delivery of recycled products and repair services. Textile waste, whether it comes from second-hand clothing entering the country or from new clothing purchased by nationals, requires a strategy to prevent it from becoming waste and to keep it as a productive factor in the economy.
  • Set up public-private alliances to undertake recycling projects and other circular economy activities through tax-extension schemes and funds to support entrepreneur- ship, innovation, and job creation for vulnerable groups.
  • Improve the legal framework for waste management, including textile recycling, by speeding up the preparation, approval, and enforcement of laws on Extended Producer Responsibility and recycling.
  • Implement a regional solid waste control plan involving inspections of sanitary landfills, clean points, and dumps to increase the enforcement capacity of regional health authorities. Enhancing the control capacity of the regional health authority concerning illegal textile dumping by implementing a Prioritized Regional Plan for solid waste control into annual territorial planning would involve conducting inspections of sanitary landfills, clean points and landfills to ensure compliance with regulations. 
  • Evaluate the environmental impacts of textile dumps. 

Pursue domestic policy action in exporting countries:

  • Make circular economy considerations central to the design of clothing, with mandatory targets to improve the quality, durability, repairability, and recyclability of garments. This includes design for disassembly and end-to-end traceability of garments and fibres, including their origin. 
  • Introduce an Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) system that holds companies that put products on the market responsible for those products after use, incentivising improvements in quality, and increases in rates of repair, reuse, and recycling. 
  • Develop more sorting and recycling plants by providing financial incentives to scale up affordable technologies and solutions that support recycling, particularly blended fibres. Policymakers should explore fiscal and non-fiscal incentives for innovation, and the introduction of mandatory recycling targets for manufacturers would stimulate the demand from manufacturers for recycled fibres.
  • Incentivise and facilitate increased levels of traceability and transparency in fashion value chains through the expanded use of DPPs, improved labelling, and more significant data collection on the flow of items domestically and internationally.
  • Run awareness-raising campaigns to encourage consumers to make more informed choices about their clothes, such as buying fewer items of better quality, renting rather than buying some garment types, and circulating clothes to peers after use.
  • Take measures to tackle fast fashion and ultra-fast fashion by, for instance, levying a fee per garment to take account of its environmental impacts, charging consumers for returning clothes after a short period (to reduce the number of second-hand clothes going to waste), restricting advertising of certain products, and mandating retailers to include an item’s reuse, repair, recycling potential and environmental impact alongside its price. 
Reversing direction in the used clothing crisis
Reversing direction in the used clothing crisis
Global, European and Chilean perspectives
  • Authored by:

    Luca Brunello, Lorena Palomo, Beatriz O’Brien.

  • Publisher: United Nations Economic Commission for Europe
  • 92
  • Supervision of Maria Teresa Pisani, Javiera Arteaga and Nanno Mulder.

 
 
  • Dated posted: 29 July 2024
  • Last modified: 29 July 2024