A PaperTale, and the Code of a Killer... App

As pressure builds up on enterprises in the business of textile-fashion to be more transparent across their supply chain, industry outreach shows there’s many a slip twixt cup and the lip.

Long Story, Cut Short
  • The Textiles Transparency Team at the MFI is researching the uptake of new technologies and aims to monitor pilot studies in the new year, including examining full scale implementation.
  • The MFITT aims to work on a set of universal directives that can be applied across the industry to ease the adoption and deployment of supply chain transparency technology.
  • Local manufacturers and retailers are in the dark about forthcoming legislation – particularly the AGEC law (anti-waste for a circular economy).
Hilde Heim
Transparency Goals The Manchester Fashion Institute Textiles Transparency research group (MFITT) team aims to work on a set of universal directives that can be applied across the industry to ease the adoption and deployment of supply chain transparency technology. Hilde Heim

An industry outreach event on digitalising supply chain transparency for small scale firms in the UK regional Northwest finds that retailers and manufacturers are seeking easy directives on how to communicate due diligence in a way that their legal (ethical and moral) obligations are met.

They also ask for a globally harmonised system.  While this might already be occurring in ISOs, the process is too slow, cumbersome and detached from firms. The GS1 system is an improvement but still too time-consuming and agnostic. It appears that the agility that tech start-ups offer is at pace with industry demands and the fluctuating demands of the market. Arguably the fashion industry could have solutions implemented ahead of the legislation by onboarding the innovations offered by start-ups. And there is a need to hurry faced as it is by the demand that the fashion industry alone will have to cut carbon emissions by half by 2030.

The Textiles Transparency Team at the Manchester Fashion Institute is continuing to research into the uptake of new technologies and aims to monitor pilot studies in the new year, including examining full scale implementation. The team will report on the processes.  Additionally, the Manchester Fashion Institute Textiles Transparency research group (MFITT) team aims to work on a set of universal directives that can be applied across the industry to ease the adoption and deployment of supply chain transparency technology.

Earlier this year,  the MFITT, led by yours truly, held the industry outreach event in collaboration with the UNECE on digitalising supply chain transparency for small scale firms in the UK regional Northwest.
 
Building on the success of that event, in late November, the MFITT team invited the founders of tracking and tracing tech start-up PaperTale, as well as representatives from the Swedish School of Textiles, to a three-day knowledge exchange series of events. The events included a roundtable forum, live challenge workshops and industry visits.

The tour kicked off with a roundtable forum including academics from the University of Manchester as well as from Manchester Metropolitan University, local government stakeholders and fashion industry representatives. This brought a diverse mix of people and expertise together to discuss the challenges and opportunities of digitalising the supply chain. 

The smart tag start-up PaperTale demonstrated their blockchain enabled app and NFC tag embedded in garments – advancing the digitalisation of the transparent and responsible supply chain.
Smart Tag The smart tag start-up PaperTale demonstrated their blockchain enabled app and NFC tag embedded in garments – advancing the digitalisation of the transparent and responsible supply chain. Hilde Heim

A ‘killer app’ for traceability?

During the visit, the smart tag start-up PaperTale demonstrated their blockchain enabled app and NFC tag embedded in garments – advancing the digitalisation of the transparent and responsible supply chain. (Showing real garments with real tags with real data on a real app!)

Associate Professor Jonas Larsson from the Swedish School of Textiles at the University of Borås presented learnings on the Swedish model of collaboration between industry, academia and government. Jonas also posed the question of supply chain transparency reporting methodologies following his visit to the SAC conference in Singapore a few weeks earlier where his team presented a sensor package innovation for data collection.

Jonas is developing IoT sensors to capture supply chain data – thus eliminating the challenge of human error in data input. His team is now actively seeking industry-based participants, that is, small scale SMEs and manufacturers that are willing to pilot the sensors — particularly in the global south.

The MFITT team facilitated workshops with Master’s students to tackle the challenges of digitalising supply chain transparency.  The students discussed their aversion to greenwashing – only to find that the industry is replacing this with so-called tech-washing – the practice of claiming to (or giving the impression of) having more advanced tech (such as blockchain), than is actually the case.
Tech-washing? The MFITT team facilitated workshops with Master’s students to tackle the challenges of digitalising supply chain transparency.  The students discussed their aversion to greenwashing – only to find that the industry is replacing this with so-called tech-washing – the practice of claiming to (or giving the impression of) having more advanced tech (such as blockchain), than is actually the case. Hilde Heim

Data verification matrix

The MFITT team also facilitated workshops with Master’s students to tackle the challenges of digitalising supply chain transparency.  The students discussed their aversion to greenwashing – only to find that the industry is replacing this with so-called tech-washing – the practice of claiming to (or giving the impression of) having more advanced tech (such as blockchain), than is actually the case. The students felt that the PaperTale app is taking the “higher moral ground” in the transparency landscape and offering what appears to be a completely transparent solution.  When asked by the students how they could verify their claims, the tech founders explained the proof behind the information on the app.

For instance, in the case of fair pay to workers, the app’s blockchain enabled platform is connected to wage remittances in a data verification matrix. Second, the workers have their version of the app and can verify that they did in fact receive their pay on time and that it was above award, as claimed. Despite the students’ (justified) misgivings about privacy, the founders claim that the workers are enthusiastic about having a voice and being able to communicate information about their working conditions. Furthermore, the consumer can send the worker an upvote.  The app also gives the workers a choice to be anonymised – or to disclose their identity publicly. The students suggested that the morals and ethics underpinning the app should be communicated more effectively.

Solution to the ‘digital passport’

Finally, the group visited local manufacturers and retailers and found that firms are in the dark about forthcoming legislation – particularly the AGEC law (anti-waste for a circular economy). This law legislated in France, compels brands to publish information like the product's country of origin and fabric in a prescribed format – as a 'product information sheet on environmental qualities and characteristics'. This regulation will come into force in January 2023 and affects firms with turnovers over a certain threshold within the country of sale.

The European Commission wants fashion companies to disclose more information (European Commission, 2022). The European Green Deal (European Commission, 2019) explains that a digital product passport might give information about a product's origin, composition, repair and dismantling options, and end-of-life treatment. The creation of a Digital Product Passport for textiles is a chance to inform consumers and improve communication along value chains, including after purchase (Adisorn, Tholen, & Götz, 2021).

Hilde Heim

Originally from Sydney, Dr Hilde Heim is a former fashion designer and entrepreneur who ran her own formalwear in France and Germany and later in Sydney, Melbourne and Brisbane. Her early investigations were on support mechanisms for small-scale entrepreneurship through digital platforms. Hilde continues her research at the Manchester Fashion Institute.

 
 
 
  • Dated posted: 13 December 2022
  • Last modified: 13 December 2022